Development Director

Guilford County

Career Opportunity

Mustard Seed Community Health seeks a strategic, relational, systems-minded, and hands-on fundraising leader to serve as its next Development Director. This is an opportunity to build on meaningful philanthropic progress, strengthen the systems that turn donor information into action, and grow a sustainable community of support for high-quality, holistic, integrated healthcare.

Reporting to the Executive Director, the Development Director will lead fundraising strategy and execution across annual giving, major gifts, grants, donor stewardship, the capital campaign, development communications, and fundraising operations. The role will partner closely with the Executive Director, the fundraising committee, board members, volunteers, staff, and community partners to advance the organization's mission.

 

Mission: To provide high-quality, holistic, integrated healthcare to those in need, in an environment that dignifies and empowers the whole person.

Reporting Structure: The Development Director reports to the Executive Director and serves as the organization’s senior staff leader for development and philanthropy. Additional support roles may be added as needed. 

Organizational Budget and Staff Size: The 2026 annual organizational budget is $1 million with a staff of 12 employees. 

Salary: Mustard Seed Community Health offers competitive compensation and a comprehensive benefits package. The salary range is $80,000-$85,000.

Benefits: The organization offers a competitive benefits package that includes health insurance premium reimbursement through an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA), a SIMPLE IRA retirement plan with up to a 3% employer match, and 120-200 hours of annual paid time off based on tenure. Additional benefits include 11 paid holidays, professional development opportunities, and reimbursement for work-related mileage. For the past two years, the organization has also provided an additional week of paid time off during a year-end holiday closure.

Location and Working Environment: This is a full-time hybrid role based in Greensboro, North Carolina. The successful candidate should live within a practical commuting radius and be available for in-person donor, staff, board, and community engagement as needed.

 

Leadership Opportunity

Build the next chapter of philanthropic growth. Mustard Seed has made significant progress in fundraising, donor stewardship, database management, and capital campaign activity. The Development Director will translate that progress into a comprehensive, measurable development strategy that diversifies revenue and strengthens long-term sustainability.

Turn fundraising information into disciplined action. The organization uses Bloomerang and needs a leader who will protect data quality, establish clear portfolios and next steps, strengthen reporting, and ensure that donor history and engagement information consistently inform cultivation, solicitation, and stewardship.

Partner closely with an engaged Executive Director. The successful candidate will bring expertise, structure, preparation, and follow-through to a collaborative partnership with the Executive Director, helping leadership focus on the right relationships and actions while personally owning the systems and execution behind the work.

Advance a culture of philanthropy during growth. As Mustard Seed expands its reach, facility, staff, and philanthropic ambitions, the Development Director will help staff, board members, volunteers, and community partners understand and participate in fundraising in ways that are coordinated, mission-centered, and achievable.

 

Key Responsibilities of the Development Director

Strategic Fundraising and Annual Giving

  • Develop and implement a comprehensive, measurable annual development plan aligned with organizational priorities and revenue goals.
  • Own and grow the annual fund through donor segmentation, acquisition, renewal, upgrade, recapture, appeals, and stewardship strategies.
  • Analyze fundraising performance and recommend practical investments, priorities, and adjustments that improve results and diversify revenue.
  • Build documented fundraising processes, calendars, dashboards, and standard operating procedures that support consistent execution and accountability.

Donor Cultivation, Solicitation, and Stewardship

  • Build and manage an active pipeline of donors and prospects, with clear portfolios, relationship strategies, next actions, and follow-up.
  • Prepare for and participate in donor meetings and solicitations with the Executive Director, board members, and other organizational leaders.
  • Create consistent stewardship practices that acknowledge gifts promptly, communicate impact, and deepen donor relationships over time.
  • Represent Mustard Seed at appropriate community events, professional gatherings, and relationship-building opportunities.

Grants and Institutional Giving

  • Lead institutional fundraising, including prospect identification, proposal development, grant calendars, submissions, reporting, and funder stewardship.
  • Collaborate with program, finance, and executive leadership to develop accurate, compelling proposals and reports tied to organizational outcomes.
  • Maintain strong records of institutional relationships, restrictions, deadlines, commitments, and reporting requirements.

 

Data, Systems, and Fundraising Operations

  • Lead the effective use of Bloomerang across the donor lifecycle, including accurate records, segmentation, moves management, campaign tracking, dashboards, reporting, and data hygiene.
  • Coordinate gift processing, acknowledgment, reconciliation, and reporting practices with finance and administrative colleagues.
  • Turn donor history, engagement information, and relationship knowledge into practical recommendations for outreach and stewardship.
  • Continuously assess and improve fundraising systems as the organization grows.

Capital Campaign, Board, and Volunteer Engagement

  • Support execution of Mustard Seed’s $3.5 million capital campaign through prospect tracking, volunteer coordination, meeting preparation, reporting, follow-up, and campaign systems.
  • Serve as staff liaison to the fundraising committee and provide members with clear goals, information, assignments, and follow-through.
  • Equip board members, volunteers, and organizational leaders to participate confidently and appropriately in fundraising and relationship-building.

Communications, Events, and Community Engagement

  • Lead donor-facing development communications and collaborate with staff and partners on cases for support, appeals, impact stories, campaign materials, and stewardship messages.
  • Provide disciplined project management for fundraising events and community engagement, including sponsorships, logistics, tracking, and follow-up.
  • Ensure fundraising communications consistently reflect Mustard Seed’s mission, impact, and commitment to dignity and empowerment.

Administrative Excellence

  • Develop and manage the development budget and recommend investments in tools, vendors, communications, events, and systems.
  • Maintain ethical fundraising and donor practices aligned with the AFP Code of Ethics and Donor Bill of Rights.
  • Balance strategic leadership with hands-on execution, including writing, database work, meeting preparation, tracking, and timely follow-up.

 

The Ideal Candidate Profile

The strongest candidates will combine demonstrated annual fund and grant success, disciplined use of donor data, strong relationship skills, and the ability to build practical fundraising systems in a growing organization. Through progressively responsible experience, candidates will demonstrate:

  • A record of managing and growing an annual fund, including cultivation, stewardship, renewal, upgrade, acquisition, and recapture strategies.
  • Meaningful grant-writing and institutional fundraising experience, including proposal development, deadline management, reporting, and funder relationships.
  • Demonstrated ability to use Bloomerang or a comparable donor CRM to maintain data quality, segment donors, manage next actions, report results, and improve fundraising performance.
  • Experience creating, improving, or scaling fundraising systems, processes, calendars, and accountability practices.
  • Strong donor relationship and stewardship skills, with readiness to build deeper major-gift capability and participate confidently in solicitations.
  • Excellent written, verbal, interpersonal, and presentation skills, including persuasive donor-facing communications.
  • Exceptional planning, organization, project management, attention to detail, and follow-through across multiple deadlines and stakeholders.
  • A collaborative leadership style and the confidence to bring recommendations, establish priorities, set appropriate boundaries, and mobilize colleagues, board members, and volunteers.
  • A bachelor’s degree is preferred. Healthcare fundraising experience, prior staff supervision, capital campaign experience, and extensive major-gift solicitation experience are welcomed but are not required.


Personal Attributes

  • Deep commitment to Mustard Seed Community Health’s mission and to serving people with dignity, respect, and care.
  • Strategic and curious, with the ability to move between big-picture opportunity and disciplined execution.
  • Relational, collaborative, and low-ego, with the confidence to bring expertise and the humility to listen and learn.
  • Data-informed without losing sight of the people and relationships behind the numbers.
  • Self-motivated, adaptable, optimistic, and comfortable bringing structure to growth and change.
  • Clear, trustworthy, consistent, and dependable in communication, follow-through, and decision-making.

About Mustard Seed Community Health

Mustard Seed Community Health provides high-quality, holistic, integrated healthcare to people in need in an environment that dignifies and empowers the whole person. The organization plays a critical role in meeting the healthcare needs of uninsured and underserved members of the Greensboro community.

 

Want to know more? Visit mustardseedhealth.org.

 

How to Apply


To apply, click on the link for this position at https://jobs.armstrongmcguire.com/. You will see instructions for uploading your compelling cover letter, salary requirements, and resume. Cover letters should be responsive to Mustard Seed Community Health’s mission as well as the stated responsibilities and qualifications.

 

Please provide all requested information to be considered. In case of technical problems, contact talent@armstrongmcguire.com. No phone calls, please, and no applications will be accepted by email or directly from third-party posting sites.

 

About Armstrong McGuire

Armstrong McGuire is a national executive search, fundraising, and strategic advising firm that believes in unlocking the potential of nonprofit leaders and the communities they serve. Founded in 2004, our diverse team of advisors works with clients and leaders to align strategy, optimize operations, build capacity, and lead nationwide searches that bring talented individuals to high-impact organizations. Learn more at armstrongmcguire.com.

 

Salary and Benefits

The organization offers a competitive benefits package that includes health insurance premium reimbursement through an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA), a SIMPLE IRA retirement plan with up to a 3% employer match, and 120-200 hours of annual paid time off based on tenure. Additional benefits include 11 paid holidays, professional development opportunities, and reimbursement for work-related mileage. For the past two years, the organization has also provided an additional week of paid time off during a year-end holiday closure.